Person    | Male 

Rev. Edward Birch

Categories: Religion

Rev. Edward Birch

Researching a plaque about West Hackney National Schools we did not expect to find the supposed straight-laced Victorians gleefully publishing a pamphlet giving the details brought out in the trial of a curate having “criminal conversation” (adultery) with the wife of his vicar.

To set the scene: Rev. Edward Birch married in 1829 and was a vicar in West Hackney. The couple met the widowed E. P. Neale in 1832 when he became Birch’s curate.  Neale “took lodgings in a house situate No. 9 Trafalgar Place, Shacklewell Lane, within half a mile of the Rectory House, which immediately adjoins the church”. The Rectory is still there, now 306 Amhurst Road, see this 1870 map. We can’t see Trafalgar Place but British History Online puts it at the west end of Shacklewell Lane, about a ten minute walk from the church and rectory. As was common for vicar’s wives, Mrs Birch worked in the parish, alongside her husband and the curate.

In the summer of 1833 Birch was going to be away for 8 days and suggested that his curate should stay at the rectory during this time. The two servants were already suspicious and so took the opportunity to spy on the wife and the curate and saw them moving between bedrooms. In the pamphlet Neale insists that Mrs Birch was infatuated with him and arrived in his bed, unbidden, at which, after a brief wrestle with his conscience, he insisted she leave.

During “a steam excursion, for the benefit of the West Hampstead National Schools”, Neale claims that he pleaded with Mrs Birch’s sister to help prevent further such behaviour. After Neale was found guilty and charged damages of £200 (c.£20,000 today), he published the 91-page booklet in which he declares his innocence: “I am an honest man!”.

That’s just our brief summary – plenty more juicy details await in The Trial of Birch v. Neale, for criminal conversation; in the Court of Common Pleas, June 25, 1835, before the Lord Chief Justice Tindal, from the notes of a short-hand writer’ with explanatory remarks by the defendant, and extracts from his brief, as laid before counsel on 6hth Feb. 1835 ... With explanatory ... By Rev. Edward BIRCH (of West Hackney.)

2024: At this time, asserting one's innocence or putting one's point of view, in a self-published statement was not uncommon. In Elizabeth Gaskell's novel 'North and South' Frederick Hale, discussing how to overcome accusations of mutiny says "No one would read a pamphlet of self-justification so long after the deed, even if I were to put one out."

Comments are provided by Facebook, please ensure you are signed in here to see them

This section lists the memorials where the subject on this page is commemorated:
Rev. Edward Birch

Commemorated ati

West Hackney National Schools

We weren't expecting the investigation into this plaque to turn up anything p...

Read More

Other Subjects

Lord Teignmouth, John Shore

Lord Teignmouth, John Shore

Anti-slavery campaigner.  Born St James Street, Piccadilly but brought up in Romford.  1769 went to work in Bengal where he was one of the first to learn a number of the local languages.  Like many...

Person, Politics & Administration, Race Issues, Religion, Indian Sub-continent

1 memorial
William of Wykeham

William of Wykeham

Bishop of Winchester, Chancellor of England and founder of Winchester College. Reconstructed Windsor Castle for King Edward III. Click on external site for more information. And see Winchester gees...

Person, Architecture, Politics & Administration, Property, Religion

4 memorials
St Benet Fink

St Benet Fink

Church destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666, rebuilt by Wren and demolished 1844.

Building, Religion

1 memorial
A. S. Diamond

A. S. Diamond

President of the West London Synagogue in 1964 and a Master of the Supreme Court.

Person, Religion

1 memorial

Previously viewed

Jessie Matthews

Jessie Matthews

W1, Berwick Street, 22, Blue Posts Pub

Unveiled by Ruthie Henshall and Andrew Lloyd Webber on 3 May 1995. Jessie Matthews was actually born a few yards away at number 94.

1 subject commemorated, 3 creators
Benjamin Clemens

Benjamin Clemens

Sculptor based in Chelsea.  Born Dalston.  Served in WW1.  Other work in London includes: Africa House Kingsway and the Burlington Arcade.

Person, Sculpture

1 memorial
Sergeant R. Baker

Sergeant R. Baker

Parishioner of St Saviour's Church Lewisham

Person

War dead, WW1
1 memorial